Does an instance know his own name?

ruby-talk
1

If a class has built checks and raises an exception if it finds
something wrong, how can I tell which instance had the error? I know
there's an object_id, but can I know the name of the objects own
instance variable?

huey = Nephew.new
duey = Nephew.new
luey = Nephew.new

duey.raise_error_on_purpose_just_for_fun #-> "Nephew 'duey' raised an
error"

Also, can an instance know his 'path' from the top-level?

class Donald

def initialize
   @huey = Nephew.new
   @duey = Nephew.new
   @luey = Nephew.new
end

end

Donald1 = Donald.new
Donald2 = Donald.new

Donald1.huey.raise_error_on_purpose_just_for_fun
#-> "Nephew Donald1.huey raised an error"

Thanks,

···

--
Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/.

2

Geoff Barnes wrote:

If a class has built checks and raises an exception if it finds
something wrong, how can I tell which instance had the error? I know
there's an object_id, but can I know the name of the objects own
instance variable?

<snip />

Also, can an instance know his 'path' from the top-level?

<snip />

No and no (at least, no sensible way). You are dealing with
symbolic names 'huey' versus actual references and objects.

The 'proper' way is to have the object know its name:

huey = Nephew.new 'Huey'

···

Thanks,

--
Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/\.

3

If a class has built checks and raises an exception if it finds
something wrong, how can I tell which instance had the error? I know
there's an object_id, but can I know the name of the objects own
instance variable?

Instances don't have names.

huey = Nephew.new
duey = Nephew.new
luey = Nephew.new

These are examples of binding an instance to a particular key (think of it in terms of a dictionary/hashtable), and not naming the instances of Nephew: huey, duey and luey.

···

On 06-09-03, at 23:10, Geoff Barnes wrote:

--
Jeremy Tregunna
jtregunna@blurgle.ca

4

You can identify an object by its object_id. Variables are just
references to an object with a convenient name for your use. If you
want to give an object an actual name, you have to pass it in as a
parameter on construction.

Geoff Barnes wrote:

···

If a class has built checks and raises an exception if it finds
something wrong, how can I tell which instance had the error? I know
there's an object_id, but can I know the name of the objects own
instance variable?

huey = Nephew.new
duey = Nephew.new
luey = Nephew.new

duey.raise_error_on_purpose_just_for_fun #-> "Nephew 'duey' raised an
error"

Also, can an instance know his 'path' from the top-level?

class Donald

def initialize
   @huey = Nephew.new
   @duey = Nephew.new
   @luey = Nephew.new
end

end

Donald1 = Donald.new
Donald2 = Donald.new

Donald1.huey.raise_error_on_purpose_just_for_fun
#-> "Nephew Donald1.huey raised an error"

Thanks,

--
Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/\.

5

Geoff Barnes wrote:

huey = Nephew.new
duey = Nephew.new
luey = Nephew.new

duey.raise_error_on_purpose_just_for_fun #-> "Nephew 'duey' raised an
error"

And what would happen if you did:
huey = Nephew.new
duey = huey
luey = duey
some_array = [ huey ]
huey = nil

duey.raise_error #=> "Nephew...uhm...duey, luey, some_array[ 0
]?...raised an error."

A variable doesn't hold an object, it holds a reference to it. Many
variables (local, global, instance, and class) can all refer to the
same object.

If you have a symbolic name that is unique to an instance, pass that
name in when creating the instance.

6

It is sort of possible to find out someone's name. The following of course, is easily breakable.
% cat names.rb
class Nephew
   def name(&block)
     names_objects = eval("local_variables.inject({}){ |h, k| h[k] = eval(k); h}", block)

     names_objects.find { |k, v| v.object_id == object_id }.first
   end
end

huey = Nephew.new
duey = Nephew.new
louie = Nephew.new

puts huey.name{}

% ruby names.rb
huey

···

On Sep 5, 2006, at 8:30 AM, Timothy Goddard wrote:

You can identify an object by its object_id. Variables are just
references to an object with a convenient name for your use. If you
want to give an object an actual name, you have to pass it in as a
parameter on construction.

Geoff Barnes wrote:

If a class has built checks and raises an exception if it finds
something wrong, how can I tell which instance had the error? I know
there's an object_id, but can I know the name of the objects own
instance variable?

huey = Nephew.new
duey = Nephew.new
luey = Nephew.new