What does this do? :

Looking at this piece of code, what does the colon do?

def partner_to(user)
    raise ArgumentError unless user
    user.id == recipient_id ? sender : recipient
end

I got the code from this rails post:
http://groups.google.com/group/rubyonrails-talk/browse_thread/thread/7fdccddde9b97ffc/6112294580b9e0ce?lnk=gst&q=internal+mail&rnum=1#6112294580b9e0ce

I'm just asking because I've never seen the colon used before.

Alle giovedì 15 marzo 2007, jko170 ha scritto:

Looking at this piece of code, what does the colon do?

def partner_to(user)
    raise ArgumentError unless user
    user.id == recipient_id ? sender : recipient
end

I got the code from this rails post:
http://groups.google.com/group/rubyonrails-talk/browse_thread/thread/7fdccd
dde9b97ffc/6112294580b9e0ce?lnk=gst&q=internal+mail&rnum=1#6112294580b9e0ce

I'm just asking because I've never seen the colon used before.

This is a shortcut for
if user.id == recipient_id ? then sender
else recipient
end

What comes before the ? is the condition (not to confuse with the ? which ends
the name of predicate methods: array.empty? do_something : do_something_else
won't work, array.empty? ? do_something : do_something_else will), after
the ? and before the : there's the action to take if the condition is true
and after the : what to do if it's false.

Stefano

You have to see the statement in its entirety. Its centered around the
ternary operator ?:

What the code is doing is:
if (user.id == recipient_id) {
  sender
} else {
  recipient
}

···

On 3/15/07, jko170 <jko170@gmail.com> wrote:

Looking at this piece of code, what does the colon do?

def partner_to(user)
    raise ArgumentError unless user
    user.id == recipient_id ? sender : recipient
end

I got the code from this rails post:

http://groups.google.com/group/rubyonrails-talk/browse_thread/thread/7fdccddde9b97ffc/6112294580b9e0ce?lnk=gst&q=internal+mail&rnum=1#6112294580b9e0ce

I'm just asking because I've never seen the colon used before.

Looks like a ternary operator (you know binary and unary operators, this is the only ternary I've ever seen)
exists in C and C like languages such as PHP

conditional_statement ? true_result : false_result

if ()
a
else
b

written as
if_condition ? result_a : result_b

one of the less lovely things to read in C like languages, but after you get used to it, it is actally a space saver.
It is relly just an conditional with two possible outcomes

Looks llike the code first checks to see if the user exists, if the user doesn't exist, you get an error message of some sort.
after that, user.id is compared to recipient_id
if they're the same, sender, else recipient

what it's for? who knows.
some kind of validation and direction.

···

On Mar 15, 2007, at 11:50 PM, jko170 wrote:

Looking at this piece of code, what does the colon do?

def partner_to(user)
    raise ArgumentError unless user
    user.id == recipient_id ? sender : recipient
end

I got the code from this rails post:
http://groups.google.com/group/rubyonrails-talk/browse_thread/thread/7fdccddde9b97ffc/6112294580b9e0ce?lnk=gst&q=internal+mail&rnum=1#6112294580b9e0ce

I'm just asking because I've never seen the colon used before.

John Joyce wrote:
> one of the less lovely things to read in C like languages, but after

you get used to it, it is actally a space saver.
It is relly just an conditional with two possible outcomes

In C the ?: operator is useful when writing macros since it's an
expression, as opposed to if/then, which is a statement. (Unlike Ruby.)
The ?: operator has been terribly abused, though, by people who believe
that you can make a program run faster by taking out whitespace.

···

--
Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/\.

Alle giovedì 15 marzo 2007, jko170 ha scritto:

Looking at this piece of code, what does the colon do?

def partner_to(user)
    raise ArgumentError unless user
    user.id == recipient_id ? sender : recipient
end

I got the code from this rails post:
http://groups.google.com/group/rubyonrails-talk/browse_thread/thread/7fdccd
dde9b97ffc/6112294580b9e0ce?lnk=gst&q=internal+mail&rnum=1#6112294580b9e0ce

I'm just asking because I've never seen the colon used before.

This is a shortcut for
if user.id == recipient_id ? then sender
else recipient
end

You got a question mark too much in there. :slight_smile:

What comes before the ? is the condition (not to confuse with the ? which ends the name of predicate methods: array.empty? do_something : do_something_else won't work, array.empty? ? do_something : do_something_else will), after the ? and before the : there's the action to take if the condition is true and after the : what to do if it's false.

Yes.

  robert

···

On 15.03.2007 15:54, Stefano Crocco wrote:

like I said it is often a difficult to read, not good choice.
It is better to just type a little bit more and make a proper conditional construct in most cases.

Tim Hunter <rmagick@gmail.com> writes:

John Joyce wrote:
> one of the less lovely things to read in C like languages, but after

you get used to it, it is actally a space saver.
It is relly just an conditional with two possible outcomes

In C the ?: operator is useful when writing macros since it's an
expression, as opposed to if/then, which is a statement. (Unlike
Ruby.) The ?: operator has been terribly abused, though, by people
who believe that you can make a program run faster by taking out
whitespace.

In effect, you are saying that ?: is the wrong way to fix a defect in
the language.

By the way, you can do something like

#include <stdio.h>
#define abs(x) ({typeof(x) _x = x; if (_x<0) _x = -_x; _x;})
int main() {
  printf("%d %f\n", abs(5), abs(-7.3));
  return 0;
}

with GCC (the obvious simplification using if/else as the last thing
in the block does _not_ work, however).

···

--
David Kastrup, Kriemhildstr. 15, 44793 Bochum

Great explanations! Thanks guys.