Ruby_critical

ruby-talk
1

Hello all

Can anyone tell me about RUBY_CRITICAL(). I want to know what this
function is about and what it does and whats the reason of ruby calling
this function?

Regards

Tridib

···

--
Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/.

2

Hello all

Can anyone tell me about RUBY_CRITICAL(). I want to know what this
function is about and what it does and whats the reason of ruby calling
this function?

it's a ruby c function. There doesn't seem to be much in the way of
documentation. Why not pull the ruby source code and read what the function
does?

Andrew McElroy

···

On Mon, Jan 30, 2012 at 8:09 PM, Tridib Bandopadhyay <tridib04@gmail.com>wrote:

Regards

Tridib

--
Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/\.

3

Hi Andrew and Tridib,

Hello all

Can anyone tell me about RUBY_CRITICAL(). I want to know what this
function is about and what it does and whats the reason of ruby calling
this function?

it's a ruby c function. There doesn't seem to be much in the way of
documentation. Why not pull the ruby source code and read what the function
does?

Out of interest, I just did that, and in 1.9.2 at least, it is defined twice, with no comments, with the form:

#define RUBY_CRITICAL(expr) do { expr; } while(0)

And all references are in win32.c.

Eep. :}

I'd hazard a guess that it does absolutely nothing at all (apart from running the supplied expression/command) in the 1.9.2 release. Perhaps it is a relic that has since been disabled, or it is to cover code that has not yet been written? I'm now somewhat curious about this as well. Since one reference is in a backward compat header, I'd put my money is on the former.

I wonder if somebody knows?

Garth

···

On 31/01/12 13:21, andrew mcelroy wrote:

On Mon, Jan 30, 2012 at 8:09 PM, Tridib Bandopadhyay<tridib04@gmail.com>wrote:

4

Hi Andrew and Tridib,

Okay, some more info:

Ruby 1.8.7 wraps the statements in rb_w32_enter_critical() and wb_w32_leave_critical(). With 1.9.2 doing nothing special with the statements, my money is on the 1.9.2 series either no longer needing, or no longer having, these particular calls.

I haven't dug into which releases in-between do and don't have these extra calls, but this might be an angle to explore if investigating the RUBY_CRITICAL macro.

Garth

···

On 31/01/12 19:38, Garthy D wrote:

Hi Andrew and Tridib,

On 31/01/12 13:21, andrew mcelroy wrote:

On Mon, Jan 30, 2012 at 8:09 PM, Tridib >> Bandopadhyay<tridib04@gmail.com>wrote:

Hello all

Can anyone tell me about RUBY_CRITICAL(). I want to know what this
function is about and what it does and whats the reason of ruby calling
this function?

it's a ruby c function. There doesn't seem to be much in the way of
documentation. Why not pull the ruby source code and read what the
function
does?

Out of interest, I just did that, and in 1.9.2 at least, it is defined
twice, with no comments, with the form:

#define RUBY_CRITICAL(expr) do { expr; } while(0)

And all references are in win32.c.

Eep. :}

I'd hazard a guess that it does absolutely nothing at all (apart from
running the supplied expression/command) in the 1.9.2 release. Perhaps
it is a relic that has since been disabled, or it is to cover code that
has not yet been written? I'm now somewhat curious about this as well.
Since one reference is in a backward compat header, I'd put my money is
on the former.

I wonder if somebody knows?

Garth

5

unsubscribe

···

On Tue, Jan 31, 2012 at 10:08 AM, Garthy D < garthy_lmkltybr@entropicsoftware.com> wrote:

Hi Andrew and Tridib,

On 31/01/12 13:21, andrew mcelroy wrote:

On Mon, Jan 30, 2012 at 8:09 PM, Tridib Bandopadhyay<tridib04@gmail.**com<tridib04@gmail.com> >> >wrote:

Hello all

Can anyone tell me about RUBY_CRITICAL(). I want to know what this
function is about and what it does and whats the reason of ruby calling
this function?

it's a ruby c function. There doesn't seem to be much in the way of
documentation. Why not pull the ruby source code and read what the
function
does?

Out of interest, I just did that, and in 1.9.2 at least, it is defined
twice, with no comments, with the form:

#define RUBY_CRITICAL(expr) do { expr; } while(0)

And all references are in win32.c.

Eep. :}

I'd hazard a guess that it does absolutely nothing at all (apart from
running the supplied expression/command) in the 1.9.2 release. Perhaps it
is a relic that has since been disabled, or it is to cover code that has
not yet been written? I'm now somewhat curious about this as well. Since
one reference is in a backward compat header, I'd put my money is on the
former.

I wonder if somebody knows?

Garth

6

Hi Andrew and Tridib,

Okay, some more info:

Ruby 1.8.7 wraps the statements in rb_w32_enter_critical() and
wb_w32_leave_critical(). With 1.9.2 doing nothing special with the
statements, my money is on the 1.9.2 series either no longer needing, or no
longer having, these particular calls.

I haven't dug into which releases in-between do and don't have these extra
calls, but this might be an angle to explore if investigating the
RUBY_CRITICAL macro.

I bet this is windows specific legacy code then.
EnterCriticalSection function was a windows 2000 call to handle low memory
situations.
It would make sense that you wouldn't want ruby to crash due to a low
memory flux while
virtual memory was being allocated.

It very well might just be a relic. If windows memory management bugs are
still of concern,
then maybe this would be an excellent candidate for a ruby gem.

Andrew McElroy

···

On Tue, Jan 31, 2012 at 3:13 AM, Garthy D < garthy_lmkltybr@entropicsoftware.com> wrote:

Garth

On 31/01/12 19:38, Garthy D wrote:

Hi Andrew and Tridib,

On 31/01/12 13:21, andrew mcelroy wrote:

On Mon, Jan 30, 2012 at 8:09 PM, Tridib >>> Bandopadhyay<tridib04@gmail.**com <tridib04@gmail.com>>wrote:

Hello all

Can anyone tell me about RUBY_CRITICAL(). I want to know what this
function is about and what it does and whats the reason of ruby calling
this function?

it's a ruby c function. There doesn't seem to be much in the way of
documentation. Why not pull the ruby source code and read what the
function
does?

Out of interest, I just did that, and in 1.9.2 at least, it is defined
twice, with no comments, with the form:

#define RUBY_CRITICAL(expr) do { expr; } while(0)

And all references are in win32.c.

Eep. :}

I'd hazard a guess that it does absolutely nothing at all (apart from
running the supplied expression/command) in the 1.9.2 release. Perhaps
it is a relic that has since been disabled, or it is to cover code that
has not yet been written? I'm now somewhat curious about this as well.
Since one reference is in a backward compat header, I'd put my money is
on the former.

I wonder if somebody knows?

Garth