Different content of Symbol.all_symbols between irb and ruby

ruby-talk
1

Hi all,

I'm experimenting with symbols and how they get added to Symbol.all_symbols. I wrote the following ruby script (saved as symbol_table.rb):

==== begin snippet ====
puts Symbol.all_symbols.size

colors = [:red, :green, :blue]
puts Symbol.all_symbols.size

rgb_values = {:red => 255, :green => 10, :blue => 40}
puts Symbol.all_symbols.size
==== end snippet ====

If I run this using "irb symbol_table.rb" the number of entries increases by 4 and then 1 as expected. However when I run it using "ruby symbol_table.rb" it number of entries is the same in all three printouts.

I'm assuming that the difference is that "ruby" parses the file prior to execution, and thus has already inserted all the symbols into the Symbol.all_symbols array. Can anyone confirm this or explain why I'm wrong?

If it matters I'm running:
* ruby 1.8.7 (2010-01-10 patchlevel 249) [i486-linux]
* irb 0.9.5(05/04/13)

Best regards,
Einar

2

I think so. lso try adding this:

new_symbol = "hello".to_sym
puts Symbol.all_symbols.size

Yo will see that in irb those are two symbols more (as irb seems to
internally use symbols for new variables) and one symbol more in Ruby
script.

···

2011/2/27 Einar Jónsson <einar@codelette.com>:

I'm assuming that the difference is that "ruby" parses the file prior to
execution, and thus has already inserted all the symbols into the
Symbol.all_symbols array. Can anyone confirm this or explain why I'm wrong?

--
Iñaki Baz Castillo
<ibc@aliax.net>